Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
abc2330 said:
Then why doesn't he seem to know it?
Click to expand...
VondyP said:
329lep.jpg
Click to expand...

Apparently he does, he just doesn't want to say that publicly!
 
abc2330 said:
He's toomuch of a wildcard for me to bet on. A scenario where he gets hurt and Tannehill retains the job is as likely as the one that you mentioned.
Click to expand...

So you're not willing to bet he's as bad as you claim he is?
 
Gut said:
So...are you saying that if he doesn't put up stats like the top 5 QB's, we should dump him and try again for a HOF qb? How many years do you give a QB to hit those numbers? 1, 2, 3, 5?

Of course we shouldn't stop looking for a Hall of Fame QB, but you don't need a HOF QB to win the SB and your odds of drafting a HOF qb are quite low. So the question is, do you throw away your chances of winning now to keep trying to find a HOF qb...or try to win now with solid qb? Obviously, Mariota and others will have to step up to earn new contracts...but where do YOU draw the line? Would you let him go and mortgage several drafts on another 50/50 chance at a 'franchise' qb who is not likely to be a Hall of Fame qb?
Click to expand...

If it comes down to Mariota at 30mil a year vs a rookie at way way less, I'll take the rookie. The production Mariota has given is easily replaced .
 
Gut said:
Except you didn't...listing the QB rating of NON-qb's!
Click to expand...
It was a joke.
Standings for a QB isn’t a QB stat. Clearly crappy QB can get a winning record because of the team around them, note VY.
We’ve also seen QB considered very good with losing records, for example many of Philip Rivers seasons.
 
CJtheBeast said:
Makes no sense
Click to expand...

Sure it does. It's a salary cap league. We will have trouble keeping players who actually merit a contract if we resign Mariota.

Any half decent rookie can provide the mediocre we have been getting for far smaller cap hit.
 
TitansWrath said:
Sure it does. It's a salary cap league. We will have trouble keeping players who actually merit a contract if we resign Mariota.

Any half decent rookie can provide the mediocre we have been getting for far smaller cap hit.
Click to expand...
I told you that people act dumb just to win arguments regarding Mariota
 
abc2330 said:
I told you that people act dumb just to win arguments regarding Mariota
Click to expand...
Yep. So cut it out. It's getting old.

It would be interesting for this site to go 1 week without posting anything about Mariota, period.
 
RTH said:
Yep. So cut it out. It's getting old.

It would be interesting for this site to go 1 week without posting anything about Mariota, period.
Click to expand...
He's making $21M this year. I think that he can handle it.
 
TitansWrath said:
If it comes down to Mariota at 30mil a year vs a rookie at way way less, I'll take the rookie. The production Mariota has given is easily replaced .
Click to expand...

Well, this will be the year to determine that. On paper the OL is better, many more weapons, hopefully Henry can run like he did last December for the whole year, no new system to learn, and potentially a better D.

If Mariota doesn't do it this year, it'll be Tannehill or a rookie or both in 2020. Let's see how this year unfolds and hope Mariota breaks out in a big way...because then we should have an awesome season!
 
TitansWrath said:
If it comes down to Mariota at 30mil a year vs a rookie at way way less, I'll take the rookie. The production Mariota has given is easily replaced .
Click to expand...
if a QB plays well enough to earn a contract, give it to them. would be pretty stupid to restart on a wildcard at the most important position in the game.
 
All depends on how he does and his health. It’s not stupid to start over if your guy isn’t consistent, healthy, or able to get you over the hump. They clearly want a super bowl run. If he sucks again this year and they sign him, it’s literally the definition of insanity.
 
JR1980 said:
All depends on how he does and his health. It’s not stupid to start over if your guy isn’t consistent, healthy, or able to get you over the hump. They clearly want a super bowl run. If he sucks again this year and they sign him, it’s literally the definition of insanity.
Click to expand...
no shit, if you're offering them 30mil then obviously those questions would have been answered
 
VondyP said:
if a QB plays well enough to earn a contract, give it to them. would be pretty stupid to restart on a wildcard at the most important position in the game.
Click to expand...

Some people prefer the mystery box to a good player

ATlhg.gif


SoreSerpentineEelelephant-size_restricted.gif
 
VondyP said:
no ****, if you're offering them 30mil then obviously those questions would have been answered
Click to expand...
Yep. They don’t believe in him 100% both on the field and health wise. He will certainly be under a lot of pressure this year like it or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top