Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
brady fits our scheme loads better than mahomes, so itd have to be brady.

LOL...I don't know...Walker and Kelce are pretty good comparatively...and while we have no one as explosive as Hill, but the quad of CD, Brown, Humph, and Taylor are more weapons than he's had. Same for Brady!

While we could debate, the purpose was for them to choose one guy versus the other...not based on scheme fit....but who is a better qb to win the SB in 2019.
 
LOL...I don't know...Walker and Kelce are pretty good comparatively...and while we have no one as explosive as Hill, but the quad of CD, Brown, Humph, and Taylor are more weapons than he's had. Same for Brady!

While we could debate, the purpose was for them to choose one guy versus the other...not based on scheme fit....but who is a better qb to win the SB in 2019.
better qb i'd go with mahomes, scheme fit brady though
 
There's a lot of QBs that consistently put up good stats but never won anything. Marino, Romo, Rivers are some that cone to mind right now. I think stats are a good indicator that a QB can play qb, but to win championships for a QB it takes more than stats they have to have the intangibles.
 
There's a lot of QBs that consistently put up good stats but never won anything. Marino, Romo, Rivers are some that cone to mind right now. I think stats are a good indicator that a QB can play qb, but to win championships for a QB it takes more than stats they have to have the intangibles.

So who would you take?
 
There's a lot of QBs that consistently put up good stats but never won anything. Marino, Romo, Rivers are some that cone to mind right now. I think stats are a good indicator that a QB can play qb, but to win championships for a QB it takes more than stats they have to have the intangibles.
It takes a team. Brady doesn't have 6 SB rings because of intangibles. It's because he's had 15 Top 10 scoring defenses in his career. On the flip side, Rodgers has had 2, and won a SB with one (the other year , his defense gave up 50 points in the first round). You can put dozens of QBs past and present with Belichick for 18 seasons, and they'll have a lot to show for it.
 
You can't make a judgment call after only one year. Let's be honest, Mahomes just finished his rookie year.
 
Thank you for your answer but let me ask you one more hypothetical for my own clarification. If you were the Titans this year and could replace him with Brady or Mahomes for 2019 ONLY...which would you take to win the Super Bowl this season?
Mahomes!!!! No question!
Brady couldn't Brady with out Belichick system
Mahomes just Balls out.
 
Never made up anything? Backed by numbers?

LOL....um...no!

You said he had qbr numbers of 24 and 44 the last two seasons...

WRONG! FACTUALLY WRONG!

You said his 4 biggest games were losses...

WRONG!

You said he's the garbage time king....

WRONG! Both JCB and I proved that with actual stats...not made up nonsense.

You make up stuff all the time! Just because we don't bother calling you out all the time doesn't mean we agree with your troll posts.
Garbage


Time


King
 
The only reason MaHomes was MVP is because the league was feeling the pressure to not make Brady the winner AGAIN. MaHomes had all kinds of weapons at his disposal and couldn't make it to the Super Bowl. Brady has had offenses full of journeymen for what seems forever and yet still keeps adding rings.
 
The only reason MaHomes was MVP is because the league was feeling the pressure to not make Brady the winner AGAIN. MaHomes had all kinds of weapons at his disposal and couldn't make it to the Super Bowl. Brady has had offenses full of journeymen for what seems forever and yet still keeps adding rings.
It’s a regular season award. Mahomes was hands down the MVP last season.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top