Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is McNair vs O'Donnell all over again.

Mariota is basically Mac9 reincarnated.

Steve wasn’t vocal, but had the respect of their team mates and was considered a good leader. (Same as MM)

Both injured a lot early on in their careers. Steve was constantly playing through something.

Steve was never really a stat guy, but he knew how to win games. You always felt good with the ball in his hands when the game was on the line (same as MM)

QB controversy. People didn’t like Steve early on. As mentioned earlier, there were people clamoring for ODonell to be the starter.

So many similarities.
 
Mariota is basically Mac9 reincarnated.

Steve wasn’t vocal, but had the respect of their team mates and was considered a good leader. (Same as MM)

Both injured a lot early on in their careers. Steve was constantly playing through something.

Steve was never really a stat guy, but he knew how to win games. You always felt good with the ball in his hands when the game was on the line (same as MM)

QB controversy. People didn’t like Steve early on. As mentioned earlier, there were people clamoring for ODonell to be the starter.

So many similarities.

There really are

Another similarity is that both always had/have tremendous respect from the players in the locker room.
 
He does not need to put up top 10 stats to stay
Why not? He has not shown he is a franchise QB. If he puts up average stats again, there is no reason to extend him. Draft a rookie and give Tannehill a modest contract extension. Last year proved this team can win with bad QB play. No reason to tie up $20m plus in an average QB.
 
Remember that time DHenry stumbled a little doing some drill early on in OTAs ir TC and people here started calling him a bust?

Its practice guys ...

No, but he has been pretty mediocre thus far, except that one month last season.
 
Mariota is basically Mac9 reincarnated.

Steve wasn’t vocal, but had the respect of their team mates and was considered a good leader. (Same as MM)

Both injured a lot early on in their careers. Steve was constantly playing through something.

Steve was never really a stat guy, but he knew how to win games. You always felt good with the ball in his hands when the game was on the line (same as MM)

QB controversy. People didn’t like Steve early on. As mentioned earlier, there were people clamoring for ODonell to be the starter.

So many similarities.
When Steve got there he had a similar bonus for leniency like MM too. MM took over for the Mett show/Jake Locker, Mac 9 took over for chandler, tolliver, Richardson, Carlson, and whatever garbage was trotted out after Moon left.
 
When Steve got there he had a similar bonus for leniency like MM too. MM took over for the Mett show/Jake Locker, Mac 9 took over for chandler, tolliver, Richardson, Carlson, and whatever garbage was trotted out after Moon left.
Moon is GOAT!
 
When Steve got there he had a similar bonus for leniency like MM too. MM took over for the Mett show/Jake Locker, Mac 9 took over for chandler, tolliver, Richardson, Carlson, and whatever garbage was trotted out after Moon left.

there was that lefty too, Will Furer or something.

Chandler was pretty good though
 
History prior to the team moving to TN is irrelevant
While I understand your point, boooooo!
Some of us have been fans of the franchise longer than Tennessee.
Moon brought me to the franchise, Mcnair and EG kept me here after the move.
 
It doesn't. I didn't say it did.

A Mary Fairy brought up his "elite" athleticism as an argument. I said his athleticism hasn't translated to good production, so what's the point of bringing it up?
You also said his athleticism doesn’t translate to something tangible. It does, just not nearly often enough.
I’d say that if Mariota was less athletic, he’d already be gone but that is part of those frustrating flashes he shows.

Honestly though, if this is the argument of keep/replace, it’s not enough by a long shot. As a characteristic, I put athleticism up there with “winner”.
 
While I understand your point, boooooo!
Some of us have been fans of the franchise longer than Tennessee.
Moon brought me to the franchise, Mcnair and EG kept me here after the move.

I've seen people argue over this a lot


Mutual understanding. Dont expect us to care, we won't expect you to not care.


I didnt even watch football until we got a team.
I'm happy it's one with a great history instead of it ending up being an expansion team though
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top