Tannehill just played awful. He would have played just the same if he got 8 reps in preseason.Tannehill
16-34 198 yards, 0TD, 3INT 47.1%
Carr
23-33 305 yards, 1TD, 1INT 69.7%
Dismiss it all you want, the point is that one QB looked ready to play today, the other didn't. And the one that DID look ready was starting for a brand new team surrounded by brand new teammates in a brand new environment. The other one was Ryan Tannehill.
I could see your argument if one guy played 2 games vs the other guy not playing at all... but 8 freaking throws? Come on.