Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Oh good, we have a thread for that! Pre-Game Thread - Game 3: Titans @ Vikings
"The most overrated coach in the history of any sport". Jeez how quickly we forget. Confirmation Bias. Jeff Fisher was a great coach. Don't know the numbers but how many coaches make it to the Super Bowl? How many have 100 wins? Not many. He got the most out of some not great players and had this team playing tough, physical and competitive for a long stretch of time.He has the potential to win that spot if he wins a sb. McNair dealt with so much and still made the titans a team that was competitive every year, even with the most overrated coach in the history of any sport. A complete joke of a coach/gm and he still won and took us to a sb. If we had a paper sack as a coach during the McNair days, we'd probably have 2 rings. But, tanny is really good and very underestimated, he could win that top spot.
Tanny 2020, got my vote
Some HC/Fisher stats:"The most overrated coach in the history of any sport". Jeez how quickly we forget. Confirmation Bias. Jeff Fisher was a great coach. Don't know the numbers but how many coaches make it to the Super Bowl? How many have 100 wins? Not many. He got the most out of some not great players and had this team playing tough, physical and competitive for a long stretch of time.
His inevitable downfall was his refusal to adapt to the new game. The Titans weren't building a team around his philosophy and he refused to evolve around the players. Imagine how creative coaches like Reid, Shanahan, or McVay can be with VY and CJ? Btw.. he also had some terrible GMs.
Time for him to go? Absolutely. Enjoy your retirement Fish. Terrible coach during the span of his career? Absolutely not! Not even close.
Just no way I could say THill is the best after essentially 15 games.
The Gase affect is real. Just wait til Darnold can get away from him.To thise of us who watched closely in Miami, NONE of this is a shock.
He was only “inconsistent” as a result of terrible OLs and worse coaching and
schemes.
There were SOOO many idiot fans in Miami, and national media aped some of their idiotic takes, but there were plenty of us who knew Tannehill was special and was being held back.
What a breath of fresh air to be in a TN uniform. Absent bad injury, he will continue to be a GREAT quarterback for the next 5 or 6 years at least. I promise you that!
Doubt it, he's too old. If he spent his entire career here, he'd have a good shot. He's 32. Unless you're a truly elite QB, you really start to go downhill in your 30s. Quarterback Age Curves
View attachment 17779
If he wins us a super bowl, sure.
Ive always liked Tanny, thank God we got himTo thise of us who watched closely in Miami, NONE of this is a shock.
He was only “inconsistent” as a result of terrible OLs and worse coaching and
schemes.
There were SOOO many idiot fans in Miami, and national media aped some of their idiotic takes, but there were plenty of us who knew Tannehill was special and was being held back.
What a breath of fresh air to be in a TN uniform. Absent bad injury, he will continue to be a GREAT quarterback for the next 5 or 6 years at least. I promise you that!
You realize with the rest of the quote, that I specifically stated him needing more time before this can really be judged. Tons of players throughout history had 1-2 seasons, no matter how great, and were never considered greatest anything.You DO know that wasnt the question right? yeah, only 15 games- hence the question “WILL HE BE.”.... not “IS HE”
Doubt it, he's too old. If he spent his entire career here, he'd have a good shot. He's 32. Unless you're a truly elite QB, you really start to go downhill in your 30s. Quarterback Age Curves
View attachment 17779
If he wins us a super bowl, sure.
Then easy no.yeah, i got that. it's a question about an unknown future base on what you see/believe/feel now.
Obviously no one has enough info to KNOW- that was the whole point of the survey, and what made it interesting. i.e., based on what you've seen, what do you think? Will he (in time)?
Ahem.history of this franchise / the QB position runs 8 deep
1- Moon
2- McNair
3- Blanda
4- Tannehill
5- Pastorini
6- Young
7- Mariota
8- Collins
After Collins it’s a stretch to fill out the final 2 - hodgepodge of meh
9- Volek
10- Hasselbeck