Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Delco78 said:
Ok guys I have a serious question. With Woodside and McDonald looking like ass so far, would you be willing to trade for Alex Smith? If not who would be a good backup?...I personally think if he is proven healthy, I'd go get Alex.
Click to expand...
If healthy and that's a big IF. Absolutely.
 
HurrayTitans! said:
Id say it’s a lot more about just recycling the same QB backups around the league.
I mean, theoretically Mccown should be the most valuable QB then.
Click to expand...
QB def seems like a pos you keep tabs on, and I know if i looked back Id find it to be a common occurrence.
 
JCBRAVE said:
you know, often
Click to expand...
Care to share some of the vast number of examples you have? I think instead of "often", it's more like "meh... sometimes... every once in a while".

At the end of the day, it's irrelevant. I won't say zero, but the value from signing a cut QB just to get an advantage on your week 1 opponent is very very close to zero.
 
Young54 said:
Care to share some of the vast number of examples you have? I think instead of "often", it's more like "meh... sometimes... every once in a while".

At the end of the day, it's irrelevant. I won't say zero, but the value from signing a cut QB just to get an advantage on your week 1 opponent is very very close to zero.
Click to expand...
It’s not zero but I believe it is 100% coincidence, not because a division team had the player.
This offseason I can think of a couple, Winston, Chase Daniel, Bridgewater. I think colt McCoy as well.

None of these guys were signed to that amount of money for the purpose of trying to “steal” anything from a division rival. They were signed to legit compete for at least the backup position.
NFL salary caps and roster sizes aren’t big enough for GMs to wastes spots and money for the off chance they may get a little information. The owner already hires other people (for much less and likely much more info) to specifically get information and tape on other teams.
 
Young54 said:
Care to share some of the vast number of examples you have? I think instead of "often", it's more like "meh... sometimes... every once in a while".

At the end of the day, it's irrelevant. I won't say zero, but the value from signing a cut QB just to get an advantage on your week 1 opponent is very very close to zero.
Click to expand...
It pops up enough I can see where @Broken Arrow is coming from
 
Delco78 said:
He is currently fully practicing in Washington . He is healthy enough to come off the pup list which means he has already passed a physical.
Click to expand...
Had not heard that. Would still say yes for a 6-7 even if we signed simeian(sp?)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top