- Thread starter
- #101
RollTide said:Of course you want to make it seem like playoff wins are all that matters but you have to get to the playoofs in the first place. Manning has taken his teams to the playoffs 75% of the time(6 of 8 seasons) mcnair just 44% of the time(4 of 9 seasons). But hey nothing matters if it doesn't make your argument right? They are only facts.
To give McNair credit, no one expected us to make it to the playoffs during most of those years. We did not have great teams. Yet we excelled despite. Manning situation is different. His teams have been built around him and for him. He is suppose to win, should win but yet he fails. McNair isn't suppose to win, can't win but does anyway.