- Thread starter
- #21
Fishface? Eddie George was over rated? Almost 11k yards to go with leadership on and off the field? The only reason George got the yards because Fishface pounded him? Thats like saying, the only reason a hockey player, or basketball gets points consistently....is because they feed them the ball. You get the ball because you earned it.Cool list Mike!
My thoughts:
- Matthews is a really hard one to slot. He is one of only two HoF on the list (and you could probably make two HoF players out of his career) but he played such a short time as a Titan
- I would definitely put Casey way ahead of Bulluk
- VY is not ahead of Mariota, come on now
- I think George is probably too high. As much as I loved him, he was never that great. He got a ton of yards because Fishface pounded him so much and was always behind a great OL
- Nate Washington was never that good. On many teams he would be WR3 at best
- I'd put Finny, Rolle and Hopkins a lot higher
- Benji Olson should be on there before the Dyson bros
- Craig Hentrich is at least as good as Kern and should be on the list. And the cherry on top was that game where he had to kick three FG (I apologise if I missed)
Last edited by a moderator: